Imitation is the Sincerest Form of Flattery
By: Collin Quiring
Just a quick muse.
The saying “Imitation is the Sincerest Form of Flattery” has been around a long time and I have been thinking about it the last few days quite a bit. I am getting ready to do a massive SharePoint Server 2010 installation and a Project Server 2010 installation. In so doing, I have been doing quite a bit of research lately to make sure that I have an understanding of how these tools are installed and the steps for setting them up and then maintaining them for the users.
In my research, I do some generic Google and Bing searches for SharePoint and Project to see what has been done by others already. And, I keep running into tools that claim to be “as good as” Microsoft Project or Project Server. But when I look at these tools that claim they are “as good as” Project or Project Server I have found that they mean that their tool does one thing and one thing only – and they think it is the same as Project. I have found this to be quite disappointing.
One tool that claimed to be great at Resource Management had a very efficient interface and did one or two things really well but as soon as I tried to do something that I normally can do in Project, I found that “as good as” didn’t mean “as comprehensive as” the Project tool. There are also add-on tools that are available for Project – some of those are great and some are useless, but at least they claim to be “add-on” and NOT a replacement that works “as good as” like these other tools claim to be.
Project might not be perfect, but it amuses me about how many tools want to be “as good as” Project and are doing their best to imitate it. In fact, some tools even give the same look and feel of Microsoft Project. It just makes me think that Project must be doing some things right if so many other companies want to imitate it!